Friday, January 20, 2023

Ed Overboard / One of Those Eds - (Ed Edd n Eddy Season 4 Episode 4) - 'Toon Reviews 52

If you like this review and want to stay updated for what else I have in store, become a follower of this blog, click here to like the official Facebook page, and click here to follow me on TwitterNow on with today's review:

Ed Overboard

An interesting thing about this cartoon is how it shows different sides to characters and puts them in unusual situations.  

To incite the conflict, there’s a look at a more humane side of the otherwise unpleasant Kanker sisters.  Lee and Marie give May a makeover, but they make their sister look like a total mess.  As May retaliates with justified aggression, she’s reminded of her supposed ‘boyfriend’ Ed, and bawls over how he’ll never like her because of how hideous he looks.  Aside from the context that Ed and his friends already want nothing to do with any of the Kankers, this is an interesting perception of this group.  The way May breaks down over how Ed might feel about her suggests that there is a genuineness to her flirting with him; perhaps her love is for real after all.  That’s not an excuse for how much of a harasser she and her sisters can be, but it’s easier to see her point here.  There’s also legit care from Lee and Marie where even though they gave May a bad makeover to begin with, they insist men can like her for more than looks.  With that said, they set out to prove it by kidnapping Ed and bringing him to May.  Of course they need to be stopped, but there are still understandable feelings from their point of view.  

Given the context and low morality, action is taken to rescue Ed from harassment.  Double D is quick to try to rescue him while Eddy doesn’t want anything to do with getting involved with the Kankers despite their friend in trouble.  Eddy may seem disingenuous, but there are strong hints of reasonable fear of the Kankers.  Then there is the help they get from Rolf who agrees to assist them as the Urban Rangers.  In fact, the way they get involved is probably the best of the series; Rolf jumps into sap to change into uniform, uses a cow to call Jimmy, Jonny, and Plank, and even lets Eddy and Double D join them through an oath.  It’s all a creative and insightful look of how this scout troop gets into action and all for a good cause for the series’ main trio.  

As for the actual rescue, a desperate need for one is clear as May is quickly cheered up by Ed’s presence. She draws symbols of love over his body, unaware that they’re unrequited.  The actual rescue features solid amusement from the characters involved. Rolf tries to stage a good distraction, and Ed naively blowing the cover of Jimmy and Jonny trying to untie him.  Their cover is ultimately blown because of Ed and the Kankers start ganging up on them, making this seemingly formidable scout troop intimidated.  In fact, their only resort is to play dead, lilies on the chest and all, but even that leaves them scared as the Kankers clearly don’t buy this act.  If there’s one thing to take from this, it makes all the times the Eds are always harassed by them slightly better.  The fact that even characters as strong as the Urban Rangers can also be overpowered by these creeps means they’re no weaker than their peers.  

If anything, the Eds turn out better than the Urban Rangers as they successfully save Ed from their clutches, and there’s even a nice scene showing how good it is to have him back.  This good feeling doesn’t last long as the cartoon ends with the Urban Rangers taking Ed away again as retaliation for the Kankers apparently giving them bad makeovers.  It’s ultimately unknown what’s done with Ed now, and things are left unresolved especially with Double D insisting Eddy be taken instead; some friendship there.  Thankfully, the sting of the ending is lessened by the impressive things this cartoon does with the featured characters.

A

One of Those Eds

Sometimes all that’s needed to pull off strong entertainment is a large cast of characters, a simple situation, and all their unique ways of approaching it.  There’s no shortage of characters with this show, all of which having their own quirky personality. With them all together to try and reach a common goal, the appeal is all set to let itself be known.  

It begins when Eddy finds a quarter on the sidewalk, but for some reason, he can’t get it off.  Worried that someone will come and take the quarter for themselves, he marks the spot with his shoe and goes to get help.  All the while, more kids show up and do the same thing.  They spot the quarter under the peculiar thing hiding it whether it’s Eddy’s shoe, Jimmy’s Mr. Yum-Yum (a bear this time), and Kevin’s hat.  Like Eddy, they can’t just pick the quarter up with it still firmly stuck to the sidewalk.  

Eventually, they all arrive at the same spot and escalate the situation claiming the quarter for themselves, eventually leading to an all-out brawl.  As an added bit of humor, all of this starting with Eddy hiding the quarter with this shoe and eventually Rolf trying to beat it with three shoes leads to Ed not fighting for the quarter.  Rather, he just goes after everyone’s shoes for the fun of it, leading to an outrageous fixation to break up the aggression.  Speaking of which, Double D’s involvement includes organizing everyone’s anxiousness to get the quarter by having them take turns in trying to get it off.  

The entertainment continues to build through everyone’s outrageous attempts and equally outrageous after effects.  Jimmy tries to remove it with an eyelash curler, and immediately is sent to the hospital after one go; Sarah tries to remove it with her teeth and is defeated by simple embarrassment after Eddy claims to see her underwear which is obviously a lie; Kevin tries to pry it off with his bike and a chain only for his bike to take off without him; and Rolf’s sheer force in removing the quarter is thwarted by a sudden relapse of a back pain caused by a scam from earlier in the cartoon.  

This only leaves the Eds in the clear to try and remove the quarter now, and when Eddy’s attempt with a shovel fails, Double D steps in with an apparently elaborate proposal.  It’s somewhat humorously remarkable that so much research goes into something as seemingly simple as removing a quarter from the sidewalk.  The build-up to the invention’s reveal is staged as huge with everything shown in shadows at night.  By the next day, this invention made of simple junk has impressively managed to dig up everything, except that quarter.  

Then, all these elaborate processes to remove it get a big punchline when what was keeping it stuck is revealed through simple measures.  It was nothing more than a wad of gum, and Jonny and Plank were using the quarter to keep it fresh.  The Eds and everyone else went through so much trouble to try and get that quarter all to themselves, but the reason it was stuck was through something so simple.  Now, all the Eds have to show for their effort is a bunch of shoes Ed managed to pilfer through it all.  

It’s plain to see that this cartoon is built through a simple scenario built upon through a big cast and creative gags, and it’s appropriately immensely entertaining as a result.

A+

Series Ranking

1.      An Ed is Born

2.      One + One = Ed

3.      The Day the Ed Stood Still

4.      A Glass of Warm Ed

5.      It Came from Outer Ed

6.      Rent-A-Ed

7.      Once Upon an Ed

8.      Fa La La La Ed

9.      Urban Ed

10.  Ed…Pass it On

11.  One of Those Eds

12.  Laugh Ed Laugh

13.  Dawn of the Eds

14.  Don’t Rain on My Ed

15.  Wish You Were Ed

16.  Dueling Eds

17.  Mirror, Mirror On the Ed

18.  Gimme, Gimme Never Ed

19.  Ed-N-Seek

20.  Keeping Up With the Eds

21.  Who Let the Ed In

22.  Avast Ye Eds

23.  Flea Bitten Ed

24.  Fool on the Ed

25.  Ready Set Ed

26.  The Ed-Touchables

27.  Who What Where Ed

28.  Dear Ed

29.  Momma’s Little Ed

30.  Brother, Can You Spare an Ed?

31.  Hot Buttered Ed

32.  Ed or Tails

33.  Stop Look and Ed

34.  See No Ed

35.  Shoo Ed

36.  Rock-a-Bye Ed

37.  Ed in a Halfshell

38.  Scrambled Ed

39.  Pain in the Ed

40.  O-Ed Eleven

41.  Vert Ed Go

42.  Ed Overboard

43.  Oath to an Ed

44.  Ed, Ed, and Away

45.  Button Yer Ed

46.  An Ed in the Bush

47.  Read All About Ed

48.  Rambling Ed

49.  Home Cooked Ed

50.  Honor Thy Ed

51.  Floss Your Ed

52.  Quick Shot Ed

53.  Look Into My Eds

54.  The Luck of the Ed

55.  Is There An Ed in the House?

56.  Knock, Knock Who’s Ed

57.  A Boy and His Ed

58.  Eds-Aggerate

59.  Three Squares and an Ed

60.  One Size Fits Ed

61.  Will Work for Ed

62.  Boys Will Be Eds

63.  High Heeled Ed

64.  Know-it-All Ed

65.  For Your Ed Only

66.  Dim Lit Ed

67.  Cry Ed

68.  Eeny Meeny Miney Ed

69.  A Pinch to Grow an Ed

70.  Pop Goes the Ed

71.  Hands Across Ed

72.  An Ed Too Many

73.  Sir Ed-a-Lot

74.  Over Your Ed

75.  From Here to Ed

76.  A Key to My Ed

77.  Once Bitten Twice Ed

78.  X Marks the Ed

79.  It’s Way Ed

80.  In Like Ed

81.  My Fair Ed

82.  To Sir With Ed

83.  Nagged to Ed

84.  Tag Yer Ed

85.  If it Smells Like an Ed

The next review shows the Eds spending the day going up (whatever that means), and Eddy stuggling to beat Plank as king of the cul-de-sac.

For the time being, all on-going review sets will be put on hold for MC Toon Reviews to put together a special review of the next Owl House finale special, "For the Future."

If you would like to check out other Ed Edd n Eddy reviews on this blog, click here for the guide made especially for them.


Sunday, January 15, 2023

Commander Anne / Sprivy - (Amphibia Season 3 Episode 11) - 'Toon Reviews 53

If you like this review and want to stay updated for what else I have in store, become a follower of this blog, click here to like the official Facebook page, and click here to follow me on TwitterNow on with today's review:

Commander Anne

Through entering the second half of Season 3, there’s a transition to a different atmosphere and focus.  Instead of the relatable homely setting of Earth, the setting is back in the fantasy category with an apocalyptic flair.  The reign of King Andrias has turned Amphibia into a desolate wasteland, stripping its vibrancy and mostly welcoming aesthetic.  It’s certainly a shock for Anne and the Plantars when they first arrive back after such a long time away.  However, that’s where the new atmosphere brings about motivation to make things right for this world.  

It isn’t long before Anne and the others find refuge in this doomsday setting upon learning what’s become of their hometown of Wartwood.  This is also where what’s become of Sasha since her last appearance is revealed as she’s taken charge of protecting Wartwood’s citizens and built up a resistance.  The resistance’s headquarters reveal several callbacks to past events of the series, most notably their location being in a secret hidden basement of the Plantars’ house.  With Anne’s return, Sasha feels more confident than ever about bringing justice to this world and doesn’t hesitate to let that be known to the crowd.  

The reason for this is soon revealed as she entitles Anne the new commander of the resistance.  All the while, Anne, and even several others, question if putting her in charge of the resistance is the best thing to do.  All Sasha says is that the reason for the decision is complicated as if to avoid sharing any details.  Anyway, the resistance sets off to take out one of the king’s bases guarded by beasts under the control of mushroom enzymes; another callback to give legitimacy to past seemingly one-off events.  

All the while, a point is made of how natural it is that some people are just not cut out for certain tasks.  Anne isn’t used to holding a position like a commander, leading to her making poor decisions that lead to dangers the group barely escapes.  This setup kind of makes sense, but it can also be kind of laughable how badly Anne messes up while in charge.  She’s planned strategies before and taken charge when things were at stake, so it’s somewhat hard to believe that managing this position would be so difficult for her.  Also, it’s kind of sad to see her arrive in Amphibia clean only to instantly revert back to how she looked during the majority of her original time there; missing shoe, leaves in hair, and all.  She really should be expected to know how to get around this world by now.  

Still, there is a point to Anne’s ineptness as commander when they reach the base, and no one is in the right shape to face the beast guarding.  Anne wisely accepts that she’s not fit for the position and insists Sasha be commander.  It’s here where Sasha reveals that the reason she’s staying out of power is because she ended up ruining their friendship the last time she sought for control.  This shows that she truly has maturely adjusted her morals and values after her recent epiphany, and Anne is quick to point that she can manage being commander because of this change.  So, after Anne willingly lets herself be eaten along with the rest of the group, Sasha is open to using her smarts to save everyone and prove herself worthy of being leader.  Still, a compromise is reached with her and Anne agreeing to share the leadership duties, meaning healthy growth for both of them as both friends and individuals.  

This shift in tone may not be perfectly executed, but it shines for its clever ideas and apparent character development.

A

Sprivy

When Sprig started a romantic relationship with Ivy Sundew, the two had a lot of potential to be a very charming kid couple.  In the subsequent appearances of them together after that, they certainly met that potential.  The problem is that there wasn’t a lot of material devoted to their relationship, making it seem not very important in the grand scheme.  This is especially hurtful to this cartoon devoted to their relationship and how prominent it is even in the face of needing to stop a tyrannical king destroying everything.  

Sprig and Ivy are apparently so close and so infatuated that they can’t bear to spend a second apart.  Such extreme attachment is too much for the rest of the resistance as well as baffling from an audience perspective.  Because so little of Sprig and Ivy as a couple has been shown throughout the series, it doesn’t feel right for them to be portrayed as this clingy.  Even if this is a romantic relationship, the show hasn’t really made it seem like Ivy is that vital of a part of Sprig’s life.  Heck, one past moment of the Plantars missing home showed Hop Pop thinking of Sylvia, Ivy’s grandmother, but not Sprig doing the same for Ivy.  For that, how attached they act towards each other ends up just as off-putting to the audience as it is to the actual characters.  

Having this unfold in something like the resistance makes it even worse as the main plot shows.  Sprig and Ivy are tasked to join Sasha on a mission along with two supporting characters from Warwood; Stumpy the local restauranteur, and Fern who works at the town spa and I’m certain hasn’t even spoken before.  The goal is to take down a robot battalion while they’re changing shifts so a delivery of important supplies for the resistance can get through.  Sasha has certain teammates assigned for certain things, but Sprig and Ivy are distressed that this means they have to split up.  This in turn leads to a very dumb decision where Sprig forges a message saying Sasha wants the partners to switch leaving him with Ivy and Stumpy with Fern.  It’s not hard to see why this is a bad move because certain talents are not being used in the right place.  Sprig and Ivy’s attempts at shutting down the robots’ force field are ineffective, and Fern gets easily distracted by things and is unable to help Stumpy when he needs it.  While Sprig can be rash, Ivy has been known to think more logically about things, so one would assume that she’d not go along with this foolish act so easily.  

Because of this boneheaded move, everyone is mobbed by robots, though getting out of the mess does make the overall message clear.  Everyone’s talents are put in the right place to avoid the force field’s power and ultimately shut it down.  Sprig and Ivy even see the benefits of this despite STILL making a huge deal of being apart for a few seconds.  For that, the cartoon gets points for nicely executing the message it sets out to teach, obvious as it is.  However, since Sprig and Ivy’s relationship hasn’t gotten a lot of attention before and still doesn’t after this cartoon, the threat to the mission’s progress feels baseless.  It acts like this romance is a huge thing in the grand scheme when it really isn’t.  

The cartoon itself has some merit, but emphasis on something that’s actually a very minor detail makes the viewing experience awkward and off-putting.  Its heart is in the right place, but it overall turns out to be pretty weak.

C+

Fan Art

Series Ranking

1.      True Colors

2.      Hopping Mall

3.      Reunion

4.      Marcy at the Gates

5.      Anne-sterminator

6.      Olivia and Yunan

7.      Toad Tax

8.      The First Temple

9.      Froggy Little Christmas

10.  Turning Point

11.  Battle of the Bands

12.  Barrel’s Warhammer

13.  Escape to Amphibia

14.  Anne vs Wild

15.  The Domino Effect

16.  The Third Temple

17.  Toadcatcher

18.  Prison Break

19.  The Second Temple

20.  Temple Frogs

21.  A Day at the Aquarium

22.  Mr. X

23.  Anne of the Year

24.  Contagi-Anne

25.  The Shut-In

26.  Best Fronds

27.  After the Rain

28.  Family Shrub

29.  Fixing Frobo

30.  If You Give a Frog a Cookie

31.  Commander Anne

32.  The New Normal

33.  The Dinner

34.  Hop-Popular

35.  Anne Hunter

36.  Wally and Anne

37.  Children of the Spore

38.  Fight at the Museum

39.  Friend or Frobo

40.  Sprig’s Birthday

41.  A Night at the Inn

42.  Bessie and MicroAngelo

43.  Handy Anne

44.  Scavenger Hunt

45.  Lily Pad Thai

46.  Dating Season

47.  Anne or Beast?

48.  Combat Camp

49.  Little Frogtown

50.  Cursed!

51.  Thai Feud

52.  Snow Day

53.  Civil Wart

54.  Maddie and Marcy

55.  Stakeout

56.  Croak and Punishment

57.  Taking Charge

58.  Flood, Sweat, and Tears

59.  Bizarre Bazaar

60.  The Plantars Check In

61.  The Sleepover to End All Sleepovers

62.  Wax Museum

63.  Return to Wartwood

64.  Sprig Gets Schooled

65.  Swamp and Sensibility

66.  Trip to the Archives

67.  Toad to Redemption

68.  Anne Theft Auto

69.  Adventures in Catsitting

70.  Hop Luck

71.  New Wartwood

72.  Ivy on the Run

73.  Night Drivers

74.  Quarreler’s Pass

75.  Hop Pop and Lock

76.  Plantar’s Last Stand

77.  Fort in the Road

78.  A Caravan Named Desire

79.  The Big Bugball Game

80.  Fiddle Me This

81.  Hollywood Hop Pop

82.  Truck Stop Polly

83.  Family Fishing Trip

84.  Hop ‘Til You Drop

85.  Spider-Sprig

86.  The Ballad of Hoppediah Plantar

87.  Girl Time

88.  Breakout Star

89.  Grubhog Day

90.  Cane Crazy

91.  Sprivy

92.  Lost in Newtopia

93.  Sprig vs Hop Pop

94.  Cracking Mrs. Croaker



The next review features another resistance mission with a varied cast, and the next big step in saving Amphibia as our heroes seek a prophecy from the Mother of Olms.

Next time is an Ed Edd n Eddy review of "Ed Overboard" and "One of Those Eds."

If you would like to check out other Amphibia reviews on this blog, click here for the guide made especially for them.